vidding, effects, and KC's big fat mouth
May. 6th, 2008 11:44 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
kricketsThis is in response to various vidding discussions that have been circulating about use of effects.
I don't believe that you're looking far enough if the only videos you're seeing recced and getting recognition are full of effects. To see this, you just have to check the last few of my recent recs. Or, for that matter, the recs over at veni, vidi, vids! Clearly, if you just look, you'll find something completely different.
I won't name names, but I know the two (non-lj) communities that are the basis for such opinions, and those are not, are quite far from, the beginning and the ending of the vidding community. And if you aren't looking outside of those very narrow boxes? Then you're just not looking hard enough.
And in regards to the question of whether or not vidding with effects is better or worse than vidding without? It's a completely bogus one. It's not even a question at all.
There are crappy videos with effects and without. Just as there are great videos with both. It's not a measure of what's good or bad. The vid itself is the measure of that. And you've just got to accept that sometimes videos that you don't like are going to get a lot of questionable praise from various corners. *cough*YouTube*cough* And sometimes the fact is that maybe that vid just isn't for you? You can't please everybody.
And you know what? Whether it's on LJ or YouTube or anywhere else? You just have to stop looking at the numbers and stop comparing yourself to other people. There will always be somebody better than you. There will always be somebody smarter, more tech savvy, more artistic, and braver than you. That's not a judgment on anyone's skills, but a simple fact based on the history of the world since... I dunno, ever.
My point is, if you're trying to quantify success by comment count? This will always be a competition.
For me, and I think for a lot of vidders out there, it's just not. When you're putting yourself up to be judged, then yes, there is that element of "will I be accepted?" And when someone is quite literally judging your work, it's hard not to take that personally.
But the action of vidding itself? Doesn't have to be that way.
This thing we do, sharing and commenting and creating and learning from each other? Does not have to be a competition. If you are on my flist and you have made even one vid? Then I have probably learned something from you. And I don't say that arbitrarily, so if you think I can't possibly mean you, you're definitely wrong.
A kind of side note: I also want to say that much of what has been said, putting down vids that use effects? Has struck me as incredibly condescending to everyone who uses effects in their vids and everyone who's ever liked a vid with effects. I'm sure no one said that any vid that uses effects is pure trash, but that's the overwhelming impression that has been given.
Feel free to disagree. Or not. I know this isn't going to sit well with several on my flist and I'm willing to accept that responsibility. If you're on my flist, you know that I am usually pretty opinionated but that it's also totally okay with me if you don't agree with me.
ETA: I'm not saying we don't strive for greatness (or even just a reflection of truth) or that we don't vid with some kind of audience in mind. If you think about it, that's what all artists do. But the process does not have to be a painful one.
I don't believe that you're looking far enough if the only videos you're seeing recced and getting recognition are full of effects. To see this, you just have to check the last few of my recent recs. Or, for that matter, the recs over at veni, vidi, vids! Clearly, if you just look, you'll find something completely different.
I won't name names, but I know the two (non-lj) communities that are the basis for such opinions, and those are not, are quite far from, the beginning and the ending of the vidding community. And if you aren't looking outside of those very narrow boxes? Then you're just not looking hard enough.
And in regards to the question of whether or not vidding with effects is better or worse than vidding without? It's a completely bogus one. It's not even a question at all.
There are crappy videos with effects and without. Just as there are great videos with both. It's not a measure of what's good or bad. The vid itself is the measure of that. And you've just got to accept that sometimes videos that you don't like are going to get a lot of questionable praise from various corners. *cough*YouTube*cough* And sometimes the fact is that maybe that vid just isn't for you? You can't please everybody.
And you know what? Whether it's on LJ or YouTube or anywhere else? You just have to stop looking at the numbers and stop comparing yourself to other people. There will always be somebody better than you. There will always be somebody smarter, more tech savvy, more artistic, and braver than you. That's not a judgment on anyone's skills, but a simple fact based on the history of the world since... I dunno, ever.
My point is, if you're trying to quantify success by comment count? This will always be a competition.
For me, and I think for a lot of vidders out there, it's just not. When you're putting yourself up to be judged, then yes, there is that element of "will I be accepted?" And when someone is quite literally judging your work, it's hard not to take that personally.
But the action of vidding itself? Doesn't have to be that way.
This thing we do, sharing and commenting and creating and learning from each other? Does not have to be a competition. If you are on my flist and you have made even one vid? Then I have probably learned something from you. And I don't say that arbitrarily, so if you think I can't possibly mean you, you're definitely wrong.
A kind of side note: I also want to say that much of what has been said, putting down vids that use effects? Has struck me as incredibly condescending to everyone who uses effects in their vids and everyone who's ever liked a vid with effects. I'm sure no one said that any vid that uses effects is pure trash, but that's the overwhelming impression that has been given.
Feel free to disagree. Or not. I know this isn't going to sit well with several on my flist and I'm willing to accept that responsibility. If you're on my flist, you know that I am usually pretty opinionated but that it's also totally okay with me if you don't agree with me.
ETA: I'm not saying we don't strive for greatness (or even just a reflection of truth) or that we don't vid with some kind of audience in mind. If you think about it, that's what all artists do. But the process does not have to be a painful one.
![[identity profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/openid.png){kind=small}
no subject
Date: 2008-05-07 01:07 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2008-05-12 03:49 pm (UTC)But without effects it's very hard to get people to fall off their chairs or drool at the mouth while watching your video
I disagree. I really disagree. Well not about the "hard" part cause making a good vid should be hard. But I think that a well edited, well executed, well thought out vid can make me drool and fall off my seat just as easily without any effects at all.